Feasibility study of use of honeybees as a bioindicator for detection of variation trends of heavy metals in the environment

Document Type : Animal environment

Authors

1 Department of Environmental Science and Engineering, Hamedan Branch, Islamic Azad University, Hamedan, Iran

2 Department of the Rangeland and Watershed, Arak Branch, Islamic Azad University, Arak, Iran

Abstract

Honeybees have great potential for monitoring environmental quality, due to their wide-ranging foraging behavior and also their inherent properties. Therefore, this study was conducted to use of honeybees as a potential bioindicator for detection of as, Zn, Pb and Ni variation trends in the environment in 2016. In so doing, a total of 180 soil, plant (including root and aerial part), honeybees and honey samples were collected from 12 stations in the main regions of beekeeping and production of honey in Markazi Province, Iran. After preparation and acid digestion of samples, the heavy metal contents were measured using inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES). Based on the results among the analyzed bee samples, as was detected in amounts ranging from 0.03 to 11.95 mg kg-1, Zn was ranged from 42.32 to 168.00 mg kg-1, Pb was ranged from 0.10 to 19.92 mg kg-1 and Ni was ranged from 0.97 to 5.74 mg kg-1. Meanwhile, the mean contents of as, Ni, Pb and Zn (mg kg-1) in honey samples were estimated to be 0.55, 11.82, 0.36 and 1.88, respectively. The results indicated that the positive correlations were found between contents of as, Zn, Pb and Ni in areal part of Astragalus gossypinus and bee samples, while, the correlations between contents of As, Zn, Pb and Ni in areal part of A. gossypinus and honey samples were negative. Therefore, it should be admitted that bees can detect more precise changes of elements in the environment and for this reason, this species as a potential bioindicator can be used to the detection of various trends of heavy metals in the environment in which they live in.

Keywords

References

  1. Achudume, A.C. and Nwafor, B.N., 2010. The ecological assessment of metals in local brands of honey in southwest Nigeria. African Journal of Agricultural Research. Vol. 5, pp: 2608-2610.
  2. Akinola, M.O.; Njoku, K.L. and Ifitezue, N.V., 2011. Assessment of heavy metals (lead and cadmium) concentration in Paspalum orbiculare near municipal refuse dumpsites in Lagos State, Nigeria. Journal of Ecology and the Natural Environment. Vol. 3, pp: 509-514.
  3. Al Naggar, A.; El-Saied, A.; Naiem Amal, I.; Seif Mohamed, I.H. and Mona, H., 2013. Honey bees and their products as a bio-indicator of environmental pollution with heavy metals. Mellifera. Vol. 13, pp: 10-20.
  4. Badiou-Bénéteau, A.; Benneveau, A.; Géret, F.; Delatte, H.; Becker, N.; Brunet, J.L.; Reynaud, B. and Belzunces, L.P., 2013. Honeybee biomarkers as promising tools to monitor environmental quality. Environment International. Vol. 60, pp: 31-41.
  5. Bahreyni, R.; Mirhadi, S.; Javaheri, S. and Talebi, M., 2006. The survey on situation of heavy metals in honey, pollen and adult bees of Tehran Province. Apiaries. Vol. 15, pp: 247-252.
  6. Barganska, Z.; Slebioda, M. and Namieśnik, J., 2016. Honey bees and their products: Bioindicators of environmental contamination. Critical reviews in environmental science and technology. Vol. 46, pp: 235-248.
  7. Bibi, S.; Husain, S.Z. and Malik, R., 2008. Pollen analysis and heavy metals detection in Honey samples from seven selected countries. Pakistan J of Botany. Vol. 40, pp: 507-516.
  8. Bilandzic, N.; Gacic, M.; Dokic, M.; Sedak, M.; Sipusic, D.I.; Koncurat, A. and Gajger, I.T., 2014. Major and trace elements levels in multiflora and uniflora honeys in Croatia. J of Food Composition and Analysis. Vol. 33, pp: 132-138.
  9. Blanco Rodriguez, P.; Vera Tomé, F., Pérez Fernandez, M. and Lozano, J.C., 2006. Linearity assumption in soil to plant transfer factors of natural uranium and radium in Helianthus annuus L. Science of the Total Environment. Vol. 361, pp: 1-7.
  10. Bogdanov, S.B.; Zimerli, M. and Erard, M., 1985. Heavy metals in honey. Lebensmitteluntersuchung und Hygiene. Vol.  77, pp:153-158 (In German).
  11. Bromenshenk, J. and Preston, E.M., 1986. Public participation in environmental monitoring; a means of attaining network capability. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. Vol. 6, pp: 35-47.
  12. Celli, G. and Maccagnani, B., 2003. Honey bees as bioindicators of environmental pollution. Bulletin of Insectology. Vol. 56, pp: 137-139.
  13. Chen, C.Y. and Chen, M.H., 2003. Investigation of Zn, Cu, Cd and Hg concentration in the oyster of Chi-ku, Taishi and Tapeng Bay, Southwestern Taiwan. Journal of Food and Drug Analysis. Vol. 11, pp: 32-38.
  14. Chirenje, T.; Ma, L.Q.; Chen, M. and Zillioux, E.J., 2003. Comparison between background concentrations of arsenic in urban and non-urban areas of Florida. Advances in Environmental Research. Vol. 8, pp: 137-146.
  15. Chojnacka, K.; Chojnacki, A.; Gorecka, H. and Gorecki, H., 2005. Bioavailability of heavy metals from polluted soils to plants. Science of the Total Environment. Vol. 337, pp: 175-182.
  16. Conti, M.E. and Botré, F., 2001. Honeybees and their products as potential bio-indicators of heavy metal contamination. Environal Monitoring and Assessment. Vol. 69, pp: 267-282.
  17. Crane, E., 1984. Bees, honey and pollen as indicators of metals in the environment. Bee World. Vol. 65, pp: 47-49.
  18. Ding, Q.; Cheng, G.; Wang, Y. and Zhuang, D., 2016. Effect of natural factors on the spatial distribution of heavy metals in soils surrounding mining regions. Science of the Total Environment. Vol. 578, pp: 577-585.
  19. do Nascimento, A.S.; Dechechi Chambo, E.; de Jesus Oliveira, D.; Ramos Andrade, B.; Santana Bonsucesso, J. and de Carvalho, C.A.L., 2018. Honey from stingless bee as indicator of contamination with metals. Sociobiology. Vol. 65, pp: 727-736.
  20. Facchinelli, A.; Sacchi, E. and Mallen, L., 2001. Multivariate statistical and GIS-based approach to identify heavy metal sources in soils. Environmental Pollution. Vol. 114, pp: 313-324.
  21. Formicki, G.; Gren1, A.; Stawarz, R.; Zyśk, B. and Gał1, A., 2013. Metal Content in Honey, Propolis, Wax, and Bee Pollen and Implications for Metal Pollution Monitoring. Polish J of Environmental Studies. Vol. 22, pp: 99-106.
  22. Frias, I.; Rubio, C.; Gonzalez-Iglesias, T.; Gutierrez, A.; Gutierrez, D. and Hardisson, A., 2008. Metals in fresh honeys from Tenerife Island, Spain. Bulletin of environmental Contamination and Toxicology. Vol. 80, pp: 30-33.
  23. Giglio, A.; Ammendola, A.; Battistella, S.; Naccarato, A.; Pallavicini, A.; Simeon, E.; Tagarelli, A. and Giulianini, P.G., 2017. Apis mellifera ligustica, Spinola 1806 as bioindicator for detecting environmental contamination: a preliminary study of heavy metal pollution in Trieste, Italy. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. Vol. 24, pp: 659-665.
  24. Hegazi, A.A. and El-Kady, A., 2010. Effect of road dust on vegetative characters and leaves heavy metal contents of Zizyphus spina-christi (L.). willd, Syzygium cuimini (L.) skeels and Olea europea (L.) seedlings. Horticultural Science and Ornamental Plants. Vol. 2, pp: 98-107.
  25. Hernandez, O.M.; Fraga, J.M.G.; Jimenez, A.I.; Jimenez, F. and Arias, J.J., 2005. Characterization of honey from the Canary Islands: determination of the mineral content by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Food Chemistry. Vol. 93, pp: 449-458.
  26. Hosseini, S.V.; Aflaki, F.; Sobhanardakani, S. and Bandehkhoda Langaroudi, S., 2015. Selected metals in canned fish consumed in Iran. Iranian Journal of Toxicology. Vol. 8, pp: 1182-1187.
  27. Jeliazkova, I.; Marinova, M. and Peneva, V., 2001. Honey bee and their products as bioindicators for environmental pollution. I. Study on mineral content of body of bee-workers received different doses of microelements with their food. Journal of Animal Science. Vol. 38, pp: 37-40.
  28. Matin, G.; Kargar, K. and Baha Buyukisik, H., 2016. Bio monitoring of cadmium, lead, arsenic and mercury in industrial districts of Izmir, Turkey by using honey bees, propolis and pine tree leaves. Ecological Engineering. Vol. 90, pp: 331-335.
  29. Mohammadi Aghamirlou, H.; Khadem, M.; Rahmani, A.; Sadeghian, M.; Mahvi, A.H.; Akbarzadeh, A. and Nazmara, Sh., 2015. Heavy metals determination in honey samples using inductively coupled plasma-optical emission spectrometry. Journal of Environmental Health Science and Engineering. Vol. 13, pp: 2-8.
  30. Mohammadi Roozbahani, M.; Sobhanardakani, S.; Karimi, H. and Sorooshnia, R., 2015. Natural and anthropogenic source of heavy metals pollution in the soil samples of an industrial complex; a case study. Iranian Journal of Toxicology. Vol. 9, pp: 1336-1341.
  31. Muhammad, S.; Tahir Shah, M. and Khan, S., 2011. Health risk assessment of heavy metals and their source apportionment in drinking water of Kohistan region, northern Pakistan. Microchemical Journal. Vol. 98, pp: 334-43.
  32. Naccari, C.; Macaluso, A.; Giangrosso, G.; Naccari, F. and Ferrantelli, V., 2014. Risk assessment of heavy metals and pesticides in honey from Sicily (Italy). Journal of Food Research. Vol. 3, pp: 107-117.
  33. Nahar Jolly, Y.; Islam, A. and Akbar, S., 2013. Transfer of metals from soil to vegetables and possible health risk assessment. Springerplus. Vol. 2, No. 1, 385 p.
  34. Ozcan, M.M. and AL Juhaimi, F.Y., 2012. Determination of heavy metals in bee honey with connected and not connected metal wires using inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectrometry (ICP-AES). Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. Vol. 184, pp: 2373-2375.
  35. Perugini, M.; Manera, M.; Grotta, L.; Abete, M.C.; Tarasco, R. and Amorena, M., 2011. Heavy metal (Hg, Cr, Cd, and Pb) contamination in urban areas and wildlife reserves: Honeybees as bioindicators. Biological Trace Element Research. Vol. 140, pp: 170-176.
  36. Pohl, P., 2009. Determination of metal content in honey by atomic absorption and emission spectrometries. Trends in Analytical Chemistry. Vol. 28, pp: 117-128.
  37. Porrini, C.; Sabatini, A.G.; Girotti, S.; Ghini, S.; Medrzycki, P.; Grillenzoni, F.; Bortolotti, L.; Gattavecchia, E. and Celli, G., 2003. Honey bees and bee products as monitors of the environmental contamination. Apiacta. Vol.  38, pp: 63-70.
  38. Rahman, S.H.; Khanam, D.; Adyel, T.; Shahidul Islam, M.; Ahsan, M.A. and Ahedul Akbor, M., 2012. Assessment of Heavy Metal Contamination of Agricultural Soil around Dhaka Export Processing Zone (DEPZ), Bangladesh: Implication of Seasonal Variation and Indices. Applied Sciences. Vol. 2, pp: 584-601.
  39. Rashed, M.; El Haty, M.T. and Mohemed, S.M., 2009. Bee honey as environmental indicator for pollution with heavy metals. Toxicological & Environmental Chemistry.  Vol. 91, pp: 389-403.
  40. Rezaei Raja, O.; Sobhanardakani, S. and Cheraghi, M., 2016. Health risk assessment of citrus contaminated with heavy metals in Hamedan City, potential risk of Al and Cu. Environmental Health Engineering and Management Journal. Vol. 3, pp: 131-135.
  41. Silva, L.; Sichul, R.; Videira, R.; Monteiro, A.P.; Valentao, P. and Andrade, P.B., 2009. Honey from Luso region (Portugal): physicochemical characteristics and mineral contents. Microchemical Journal. Vol. 93, pp: 73-77.
  42. Skorbiłowicz, M.; Skorbiłowicz, E. and Cieśluk, I., 2018. Bees as bioindicators of environmental pollution with metals in an urban area. Journal of Ecological Engineering. Vol. 19, pp: 229-234.
  43. Sobhanardakani, S., 2018. Non-carcinogenic risk assessment of heavy metals through exposure to the household dust (Case study: City of Khorramabad, Iran). Annals of Military and Health Sciences Research. Vol. 16, No. 4, e86594.
  44. Sobhanardakani, S. and Ghoochian, M., 2016. Analysis of heavy metals in surface sediments from Agh Gel Wetland, Iran. Iranian Journal of Toxicology. Vol. 34, pp: 41-46.
  45. Sobhanardakani, S. and Jafari, S.M., 2014. Assessment of heavy metals (Cu, Pb and Zn) in different tissues of common carp (Cyprinus carpio) caught from Shirinsu Wetland, Western Iran. J of Chemical Health Risks. Vol. 4, pp: 47-54.
  46. Sobhanardakani, S. and Jamshidi, K., 2015. Assessment of metals (Co, Ni and Zn) content in the sediments of Mighan Wetland using geo-accumulation index. Iranian Journal of Toxicology. Vol. 30, pp: 1386-1390.
  47. Sobhanardakani, S. and Kianpour, M., 2016. Heavy metal levels and potential health risk assessment in honey consumed in west of Iran. Avicenna Journal of Environmental Health Engineering. Vol. 3, e7795.
  48. Sobhanardakani, S.; Tayebi, L. and Hosseini, S.V., 2018. Health risk assessment of arsenic and heavy metals (Cd, Cu, Co, Pb, and Sn) through consumption of Caviar of Acipenser persicus from Southern Caspian Sea. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. Vol. 25, pp: 2664-2671.
  49. Soriano, M.A. and Fereres, E., 2003. Use of crops for in situ phytoremendiation of polluted soil following a toxic flood from a mine spill. Plant and Soil. Vol. 256, pp: 53-64.
  50. Soylak, M. and Doghan, M., 2000. Lead concentration of dust sample from Nigde city Turkey. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin. Vol. 9, pp: 36-40.
  51. Stecka, H.; Jedryczko, D.; Welna, M. and Pohl, P., 2014. Determination of traces of copper and zinc in honeys by the solid phase extraction pre-concentration followed by the flame atomic absorption spectrometry detection.  Environmental monitoring & assessment. Vol. 186, pp: 6145-6155.
  52. Tuzen, M. and Soylak, M., 2005. Trace heavy metal levels in microwave digested honey samples from MiddleAnatolia, Turkey. J of Food and Drug Analysis. Vol. 13, pp: 343-347.
  53. Wang, A.S.; Angle, J.S.; Chaney, R.L.; Delorme, T.A. and Reeves, R.D., 2006. Soil pH effects on uptake of Cd and Zn by Thlaspi caerulescens. Plant & soil. Vol. 281, pp: 325-337.
  54. Yang, ZH.; Lu, W.; Long, Y.; Bao, X. and Yang, Q., 2011. Assessment of heavy metals contamination in urban topsoil from Changchun City, China. Journal of Geochemical Exploration. Vol. 108, pp: 27-38.
  55. Yoon, J.; Cao, X.; Zhou, Q. and Ma, L.Q., 2006. Accumulation of Pb, Cu, and Zn in native plants growing on a contaminated Florida site. Science of the Total Environment. Vol. 368, pp: 456-464.
  56. Zaric, N.M.; Ilijevic, K.; Stanisavljevic, L. and Grzetic, I., 2017. Use of honeybees (Apis mellifera L.) as bioindicators for assessment and source appointment of metal pollution. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. Vol. 24, pp: 25828-25838. 
  57. Zhelyazkova, I., 2012. Honeybees bioindicators for environmental quality. Bulgarian Journal of Agricultural Science. Vol. 18, pp: 435-442.
Journal of Animal Environment
Volume 12, Issue 2
April 2020
Pages 299-310

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics